How Reliable Are Yours Students’ Resources?
Saturday, April 3rd, 2010The first thing high school Speech and Debate teacher Brenda Stewart teaches her students when they begin debate class is that the phrase, “I read it on the Internet” is not a usable source in a debate. “You wouldn’t believe some of the facts these students were coming up with,” she said, laughing. “I’ve had to start out, right off the bat, by telling them to be leery of internet sites as credible sources of information.”
This month at WeAreTeachers, we are teaming up with Encyclopedia Britannica to offer our “Quality Counts” microgrant. We want teachers to share their favorite research project they do with their students each year and their strategies for ensuring that students are getting accurate, quality information when so much of what they read online may be misleading or false. Let us know and you could win $200 and a Flip Video camera to show how your favorite student project that supports connecting students with reliable resources for information.
In conjunction with this microgrant, we wanted to take a minute to explore misinformation on the internet and to offer a solution to screen for accurate information.
While some sites are obviously trustworthy, you might be surprised by what is being passed along as facts and are clearly fabrications. Take a look at this video from YouTube of a kayaker being capsized by a killer whale and then emerging unscathed.
You might think that YouTube would surely offer quality information, so this video must be real. You would be wrong. Despite the fact that the description of the video reads, ” Some people out on the ocean enjoying a Kayak ride… When all of a sudden a whale capsizes one of the Kayaks! Lucky no one got hurt! Just very surprised,” a search on the urban legend debunking website Snopes reveals that the video is a fake.
“However, this clip…isn’t the real thing,” Snopes reports. “It’s part of a Korean language version of a commercial for Powerade…noted for producing commercials using a variety of tricky visual effects to depict athletes accomplishing impossible feats of strength and and skill.”
It’s easy to verify viral email forwards or urban legends thanks to sites like Snopes, but what about the information that your students are using? In a time when so much information is free, how can you make sure that your students aren’t getting what they pay for? That is to say, how can you be sure that the content they are using for reference and information is credible?
The solution lies in the acronym CARS (Credibility, Accuracy, Reasonability, Support). The CARS checklist is an excellent way to help students discern between quality information online and inaccuracies parading as the truth:
Credibility: Is the information from a site considered to be an authority? That is a great starting point, but as we saw with the YouTube clip, it does not stand alone as a way to determine quality information.
Accuracy: Was the article written recently? Remember, there is no one in charge of sifting through the internet and deleting information that is no longer relevant. Check your dates. Is the language vague, or does it offer specific information?
Reasonability: Does it just sound too good to be true? Does it sound excessive? Does it make sense? If not, tread lightly-it’s probably not true.
Support: Lastly, are there footnotes? Links? Listed sources? Contact information? Collaborating evidence? Without any evidence to back up a claim, it’s difficult to know if it is true or not.
If your fact does not meet the CARS criteria, you should probably keep looking until you find information that does.
We are looking forward to hearing your solutions for keeping information pertinent and credible. Have you applied for our microgrant yet? Don’t wait-do it now and be well on your way to earning cash and a Flip Video camera! The deadline for applications is April 6, so don’t wait-apply now!
If you will be in Austin this weekend, we hope you will set aside time to join us for a TweetUp, sponsored by 

![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_e.png?x-id=a1d36e5b-51da-4bca-abdb-7a7f06ab8893)

![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_e.png?x-id=6a0b3784-7993-43b3-b75f-a5d537841c80)

![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_e.png?x-id=2ecd1587-0c9f-4150-bc60-3e5f30dcea12)






